Lloyd-Jones on Preaching and the Use of Media
Here is recent post that Tim Keller wrote with regard to Martyn Lloyd-Jones’ statements about the primacy of preaching. In the course of the post, Keller mentions the Doctor’s warnings about the use of recorded sermons. I remember hearing Lloyd-Jones’ strong warnings against the use of audio recordings, while listening (the irony of it all) to his Preachers and Preaching lectures in seminary. I didn’t fully grasp, then, what he concerned about; having seen all the anti-ecclesiastical abuse over the years, I better understand the caution. Keller writes:
Dr. Lloyd-Jones effectively dismantles the idea that watching a video or listening to an audio of a sermon is as good as coming physically into an assembly and listening to a sermon with a body of people. It is obviously a good thing if a person who never hears or reads the Bible listens to the recording of a good gospel message and is helped by it. But the Doctor argues that people experience the sermon in a radically different way if they hear it together with a body of listeners and if they see the preacher. Watching on a screen or listening as you walk detaches you and the sermon becomes mere information, not a whole experience. There is a power and impact that the media cannot convey.
I think you’ll find the rest of Keller’s digestion and thoughts to be timely and beneficial.
RT: Justin Taylor
Lloyd-Jones didn’t just say listening to a sermon is not as good as hearing it in the preacher’s presence, he disapproved of recording sermons (even though his were recorded). His point, and he is quite right, is that taking taking the preached word out of the context of worship – not to mention putting it in common forms which would now include church websites – steals away the holiness of God’s word. We never want to feel improperly comfortable with the word of God (Isa 66:2).
Lloyd-Jones goes on to basically say the more we are caught up with and rely on material things in worship – speaking in particular to the issue of music – the less spirituality you are going to have. He didn’t appeal to it, but I believe this is supported by what Jesus is saying in Jn 4 (see G Vos, RHBI) and consider Eph 5:18 in light of Lev 10.
So can we count Keller as officially being against multi-site churches? I hope so.