Carl Trueman Against Narnia, Pro Golden Compass?

Carl Trueman has a very interesting, and I believe accurate, analysis of the way Christians are reacting to the movie The Golden Compass. Trueman’s premise is simple. When The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe came out Christians made a huge deal out of it as if it was the most theologically sound movie ever produced. In fact, Lewis paints an inadequate view of the atonement that Trueman suggests will lead your children astray if they really believe it is the biblical view. That being said, perhaps Christians should not speak out so vehemently against an explicitely non-Christian movie–unless they are willing to boycott everything that is not biblical. I suppose I might take a via media by saying that I could watch Narnia through the lens of Reformed theology (or at least critique it for myself and my family through that lens) while I might not go to see Golden Compass at all (unless of course it is for shere entertainment value, the way I would watch a cartoon like the Simpsons for the same reason). Anyway, Trueman’s post is thought provoking. You can read it here and decide for yourself.